Skip to Content

30 Common Gardening Myths Debunked

As a gardener, you often encounter numerous misconceptions, from watering practices to pest control. This post’ll uncover the truth behind 30 common gardening myths and provide accurate information to help you cultivate a thriving garden.

Let’s dive in and start debunking!

Gardening Myths

Gardening Myths on Additives


Myth 1: Adding sand to heavy clay soil will improve its texture.

Reality: Mixing sand into clay soil can create a hard, cement-like texture. Instead, amend clay soil with organic matter, such as compost, which improves soil structure and promotes better drainage. You can get a compost bin on Amazon.

Myth 2: Adding sugar to the soil will help plants grow better.

Reality: Plants produce their own sugars through photosynthesis. Adding sugar to the soil can actually harm them by promoting the growth of harmful bacteria and fungi.

Myth 3: Epsom salts cure all plant problems.

Reality: Epsom salts can provide magnesium essential for plant growth. However, they should only be used if a magnesium deficiency is diagnosed. Using Epsom salts unnecessarily can cause nutrient imbalances in the soil.

Myth 4: Using eggshells as a slug deterrent is effective.

Reality: While eggshells can provide a temporary barrier, their sharp edges break down relatively quickly and lose their effectiveness. Other slug control methods may be more effective, such as traps, bait, or diatomaceous earth.

Myth 5: Placing a banana peel in the hole when planting roses will make them grow better.

Reality: While banana peels provide potassium, they won’t significantly impact rose growth. A balanced fertilizer or compost is more effective for promoting healthy plant growth.

Myth 6: Plants should be fed with coffee grounds for extra nutrients.

Reality: While used coffee grounds can provide some nutrients, they can also make the soil too acidic for certain plants. It’s better to use a balanced fertilizer or compost to provide nutrients.

Tree Gardening Myths

Apple on trees in orchard in fall season

Myth 7: You should always stake new trees for support.

Reality: Staking is sometimes necessary for very young or unstable trees, but over-staking can inhibit root development and make the tree dependent on the stake. Only stake trees when necessary, and remove them once the tree can support itself.

Myth 8: Pruning wounds need to be sealed with wound paint.

Reality: Research has shown that wound paint can actually slow down the healing process and may encourage the growth of harmful pathogens. Trees can generally heal themselves, and proper pruning techniques minimize the risk of infection.

Myth 9: Trees should be planted with their root flare completely covered.

Reality: The root flare should be just above soil level, where the roots begin to spread out from the trunk. Planting a tree too deeply can lead to poor oxygen exchange, root rot, and reduced tree health.

Myth 10: You must prune all dead or diseased branches immediately.

Reality: While removing diseased branches to prevent the spread of pathogens is essential, some dead branches can be left on the tree to provide habitat for beneficial insects and other wildlife. Use discretion and consider the overall health of the tree before pruning.

Gardening Myths From Pests to Pesticides

french marigold

Myth 11: All bugs in the garden are pests.

Reality: Many insects benefit the garden, aiding in pollination, pest control, and decomposition. It’s important to identify the insects in your garden and encourage the presence of beneficial insects while managing the harmful ones.

Myth 12: Planting marigolds deters all pests.

Reality: Marigolds can help repel certain pests, such as nematodes and some aphids. However, they are not a universal pest deterrent. Integrated pest management strategies, including companion planting, biological controls, and targeted treatments, are more effective for controlling many pests.

Myth 13: Organic gardening means no pesticides or fertilizers.

Reality: Organic gardening involves using natural methods and materials to manage pests and provide nutrients to plants. This can include the use of organic pesticides and fertilizers derived from natural sources. The key is to use these products responsibly and in accordance with organic gardening principles.

Myth 14: All mushrooms in the garden are poisonous and should be removed.

Reality: Many mushrooms are harmless and can even be beneficial, breaking down organic matter and returning nutrients to the soil. Only remove mushrooms if they pose a risk to children or pets, and always exercise caution when handling unfamiliar fungi.

Garden Watering Myths

watering sage in the garden

Myth 15: New seedlings should be watered from the top.

Reality: Watering seedlings from the top can dislodge seeds or wash away soil. Bottom watering, where water is added to a tray beneath the seedlings, encourages deeper root growth and reduces the risk of damaging the delicate seedlings.

Myth 16: Drought-tolerant plants don’t need water.

Reality: Drought-tolerant plants can survive with less water than other plants, but they still require water, especially during establishment. Once established, these plants can withstand longer periods without water, but occasional deep watering is still beneficial.

Myth 17: You should water your lawn every day.

Reality: Overwatering can lead to shallow root systems and promote the growth of weeds and diseases. Watering your lawn deeply and less frequently is better, allowing the soil to dry out slightly between waterings.

Myth 18: Watering plants during the day will burn their leaves.

Reality: While it’s true that water droplets can act like a magnifying glass and focus sunlight, the likelihood of this causing significant damage to plant leaves is quite low. It’s best to water plants in the morning or evening to reduce water evaporation, rather than out of fear of burning them.

Myth 19: Gravel in the bottom of pots improves drainage.

Reality: Adding gravel to the bottom of a pot can actually reduce drainage by creating a “perched water table,” which can cause water to accumulate above the gravel layer. Instead, use a well-draining potting mix and ensure the pot has drainage holes.

Planting Myths

Peat-based Soil for Zahara Zinnias

Myth 20: You can’t plant anything new in the fall.

Reality: Fall is an excellent time to plant many types of trees, shrubs, and perennials. The cooler temperatures and increased rainfall help plants establish strong root systems before winter.

Myth 21: Always plant seeds as deep as the seed is wide.

Reality: Planting depth varies depending on the seed type. Small seeds, like lettuce or carrots, require shallow planting, while larger seeds, such as beans or squash, need to be planted deeper. Always follow the seed packet’s instructions for optimal germination.

Myth 22: Native plants don’t need maintenance.

Reality: While native plants are generally better adapted to local conditions and require less care than non-native species, they still need some maintenance like pruning, watering, and pest control to keep them healthy and thriving.

Myth 23: You can’t grow plants in small spaces or without a garden.

Reality: Container gardening, vertical gardening, and indoor gardening are all viable options for growing plants in limited spaces. Many vegetables, herbs, and ornamental plants can thrive in pots or other small containers.

Gardening Maintenance Myths

Weeding soil for lemon trees

Myth 24: More fertilizer is always better for plants.

Reality: Over-fertilizing can be harmful to plants, causing “fertilizer burn” or an imbalance of nutrients in the soil. It’s important to follow the recommended application rates and schedules for each type of fertilizer.

Myth 25: All weeds are bad and should be removed.

Reality: Some weeds can be beneficial, providing habitat for insects, improving soil structure, or even offering edible or medicinal uses. Properly identifying weeds and understanding their role in the garden can help you make informed decisions about their management.

Myth 26: It’s necessary to rotate crops in a home garden.

Reality: Crop rotation is more important for large-scale agriculture to prevent the buildup of pests and diseases. In a small home garden, proper soil care and pest management can mitigate most risks associated with planting the same crop in the same place each year.

Myth 27: All plants need full sun to grow well.

Reality: Different plants have different light requirements. While many vegetables and flowers require full sun, plenty of shade-tolerant plants can thrive in less sunny areas of the garden.

Myth 28: You should remove all grass clippings after mowing.

Reality: Leaving grass clippings on the lawn after mowing can act as a natural fertilizer, returning nutrients to the soil as they decompose. This practice, known as “grasscycling,” can reduce the need for synthetic fertilizers.

Myth 29: Pine needles make the soil too acidic for most plants.

Reality: Pine needles break down slowly and have a minimal impact on soil pH. In fact, they can be used as an excellent, long-lasting mulch that helps conserve soil moisture and suppress weeds.

Myth 30: You should always remove the lower leaves of tomato plants.

Reality: While removing some lower leaves can improve air circulation and reduce the risk of disease, it’s essential not to over-prune. Leaves are necessary for photosynthesis, and excessive pruning can reduce the plant’s ability to produce energy, ultimately affecting fruit production.

The Reality of Gardening Myths Debunked

Now that we’ve dispelled these 30 common gardening myths share your newfound knowledge with other gardeners and growers. And if you’re ready to take your gardening know-how to the next level, learn about the benefits of gardening for mental health.

Want more garden content? Visit our gardening page for in-depth guides, explainer posts, and great ideas!