A tomato mill is a wonderful addition for any household or kitchen trying to become more sustainable. Acquiring one of the best tomato mills will save you time and energy when prepping your meals and your pantry.
Unlike a sieve, a tomato mill does all of the work for you. You don’t have to prep your tomatoes for the food mill, which cuts out work hours.
Get a food mill if you are serious about canning and food preservation but are still time-conscious.
Keep reading to discover the best food mill for your kitchen.
Our Top Picks
Best Overall:
The OXO Good Grips Food Mill
Best Electric Tomato Mill:
Weston Electric Food Mill
Most Value:
Gourmet Artiste Food Mill
Best Overall
The OXO Good Grips Food Mill
The OXO Good Grips Food Mill is a high-quality kitchen tool that makes it easy to puree, strain, and mill food.
This food mill is sturdy. It’s cost-effective without compromising on quality. Not only does it assemble easily, but it also comes apart for easy cleaning.
The silicone-coated handle provides a comfortable food-grinding experience, and the foldout legs will grip almost any kitchen bowl you have without slipping.
The mill is made of durable, high-quality materials and features a comfortable, non-slip grip.
The three interchangeable disks make it easy to achieve the desired consistency, whether you’re making tomato sauce, mashed potatoes, or apple sauce.
Cleanup is a breeze, as the mill is dishwasher safe. It can be difficult to clean around the mill if you wash this by hand. This would be a great first-time tomato mill for your kitchen.
Pros
- Durable construction using high-quality materials.
- Comfortable, non-slip grip for ease of use.
- Interchangeable disks for versatile milling options.
- Easy to clean and dishwasher safe.
- Saves time and effort in the kitchen.
Cons:
- It can be difficult to clean around the mill.
Best Electric Tomato Mill
Weston Electric Food Mill
The Weston Electric food mill is a practical option for people who can’t manually crank their food mill.
This innovative kitchen tool makes it easy to puree, strain, and mill food. The electric design eliminates the need for manual cranking, making it a great choice for those who want to save energy in the kitchen.
There is no hand cranking needed to get a pureed tomato sauce. This electric food mill is slow and steady. It might take more time to grind your tomatoes to the ideal texture than manual options, but it will be easier on your hands and get the job done.
Something to keep in mind with the Weston Electric Food Mill is that you will have to press a button to keep it grinding your food. If a hands-off option is your preference, this is not the tomato mill for you.
The mill is made of high-quality materials and features three interchangeable disks for versatile milling options.
The removable bowl and blades make it easy to clean, and the compact design makes it easy to store.
Overall, the Best Electric-Weston Electric Food Mill is an excellent kitchen tool for making food prep easier and more efficient.
Pros
- The electric design eliminates manual cranking, saving time and energy.
- Interchangeable disks for versatile milling options.
- Easy to clean with removable bowl and blades.
Cons
- You have to press a button for the duration of the food milling process.
Most Value
Gourmet Artiste Food Mill
The Gourmet Artiste food mill is a very sturdy, reliable, and cost-effective food mill. You can’t go wrong with choosing this, especially if you’re looking to purchase a food mill for the first time.
The mill is made of durable, food-grade materials and features three interchangeable disks for versatile milling options.
The ergonomic handle and non-slip base on this tomato mill provide a comfortable and secure grip, making it easy to use.
Cleanup is a breeze, as the mill is dishwasher safe.
Even better, Gourmet Artiste will refund or replace your food mill if you have any issues. That is quality guaranteed!
This product also includes an e-book with 21 recipes that have follow-along videos. If you’re new to food mills and want to use your product fully, this is the tomato mill for you.
Pros
- Easy to clean and dishwasher safe.
- An E-book with 21 recipes is included.
Cons
- It can be difficult to clean around the disk housing.
Rösle Stainless Steel Food Mill
The Rösle food mill is a pricier option, but it’s worth it.
Sometimes, splurging on an item doesn’t guarantee that it will be of better quality. With the Rösle, you are guaranteed an amazing food mill that will last for generations.
The mill is made of high-quality stainless steel, making it durable and rust-resistant. It also works faster than other tomato mills. It is a smooth process to get you the best purees and sauces.
The two interchangeable disks provide versatile milling options, while the handle and non-slip base provide a comfortable and secure grip. Cleanup is easy, as the mill is dishwasher safe.
This is truly worth the cost.
Pros
- Made of durable, rust-resistant stainless steel.
- Comfortable ergonomic handle and a non-slip base.
Cons
- Contains only two mesh sieves. Most mills come with three.
- More expensive compared to other food mills.
Green Sprouts Fresh Baby Food Mill
Although you can use any food mill to make baby food, the Green Sprouts baby food mill is worth the purchase!
Having a food mill specifically for baby food will make your life easier. You will be able to make exactly how much food you need without having to figure out how to store big batches.
The mill is made of food-grade materials and is BPA-free, ensuring the safety of your baby’s food.
The compact design makes it easy to store and transport, making it a great choice for on-the-go meals. Whether on a picnic or out to dinner, you can take cooked potatoes or fruit and turn it into a meal for your baby. It is lightweight and small enough to fit into a standard diaper bag.
The mill is also easy to clean, as it is dishwasher safe.
In addition, when your baby becomes a toddler, it can help make applesauce and pasta sauce with it. Including them in the process of making food is an invaluable life skill.
Consider purchasing the Green Sprouts baby food mill to help make memories with your baby.
Overall, the Green Sprouts Fresh Baby Food Mill is a kitchen tool for parents who want to create delicious and healthy meals for their baby while saving time and effort in the kitchen.
Pros
- Made of food-grade materials and BPA-free for baby’s safety.
- Compact design for easy storage and transport.
Cons
- Not be suitable for milling large quantities at once.
- It is made out of plastic.
Tomato Mill Recipes
Your tomato mill will help you get the most use out of your homegrown tomatoes.
With your tomato mill, you can make your own marinara sauce with your milled tomatoes. This is so versatile–you can use it for almost any Italian-inspired recipe in your kitchen.
Make your own tomato soup without having to worry about an unsavory texture from the pulp and seeds. You can also make a tomato bisque soup with your food mill.
With the tomato mill, your mind is the limit for unique tomato-based meals!
How to Get the Most Out of the Best Tomato Mills
If you’re worried about your food mill sitting in a cupboard for most of the year, don’t despair. You can also use this handy device to make mashed potatoes, applesauce, jellies, and more.
Check out some of these non-tomato recipes to make with your food mill:
With a food mill, there are a lot of possibilities. From preserves to mashed potatoes and creamy soups to pureed fruits, the food mill can shift your relationship with making food.
What To Look For In Product
Manual vs. Electric
Choosing the best tomato food mill to purchase can be tricky.
Modern-day food mills are built to be easy to grind. Most handles have silicone padding for comfort and to reduce hand fatigue. Because there are no motorized parts, manual tomato mills last longer and give you control over your puree texture.
They also process a larger quantity of food than most electric food mills.
Electric wet food mills can be harder to come by. The demand for electric wet food mills is limited, as manual food mills are more commonly used for wet foods.
In addition, they are not a completely hands-free experience. Like the Weston electric food mill, you might have to hold to button down to grind your food.
Size
Size matters!
Some food mills will be larger than most home cooks need on a day-to-day basis. A food mill that has a two-quart capacity will suit most kitchens. If you plan to sell jams and other canned foods, you might want to look for a higher-capacity food mill.
Milling Discs
If you’re new to food mills, you might not understand the purpose of milling discs. They’re essentially sieves that do the work for you. When choosing your food mill, consider the recipes you’ll make. Most food mills contain milling discs to process both seeded and dense foods.
For example, a disc with smaller holes is used for tomatoes, raspberries, and other fine-seeded foods. The disc keeps tiny seeds from getting into your purees.
A disc with bigger holes works better for foods like potatoes and carrots.
Most tomato mills will contain three sieves. The Rösle, on the other hand, only contains two sieves so be sure to note what accessories are included.
Cleaning and Storing
Cleaning and storing a new kitchen gadget can be a make-it or break-it factor in your purchasing decision. If you have a busy household, buying a tomato mill that allows for easy cleanup and storage is important.
Most food mills will have multiple parts for assembly. Although cleaning multiple parts can be time-consuming, it ensures you don’t have food particles stuck in hard-to-reach places. The OXO Good Grips and Gourmet Artiste food mills seem comparable in terms of cleanup.
It’s best to rinse and wash your food mill right after using it. If you wait too long, your pureed fruits and vegetables can cake onto the small holes of the sieves and can corrode the stainless steel.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need a tomato mill if I have a food processor?
Food processors are great for pureeing food like soup. However, if you want a tool that separates seeds and pulp from an otherwise smooth puree, a tomato mill is what you need.
A food mill is also a great purchase because there are models that don’t require electricity or batteries to use them. If the electricity is out and you still need to make food, your food mill can help you make meals.
Is it worth buying a food mill?
A food mill is an appliance for you if you process large batches of food. If you have milling needs on a smaller scale, check out the Green Spouts Food Mill–it’s not just for baby food!
Does my food have to be at room temperature to use a food mill?
The great thing about a food mill is that it can be used to process both hot and cold foods! Unlike a blender, you don’t have to worry about overheating this appliance.
A Must-Have Product!
The best tomato mill will save you time and effort while processing tomatoes.
If you know you’ll have a large tomato harvest on your hands this year, or you just want to have more homemade items in your pantry, investing in a tomato mill is the way to go!
If you need guidance on how to grow the best tomatoes in your food mill, go to our tomato plants page for all your growing needs.